Response to Will's Main Blog
I have to admit that until this
point, I had never seen any of Sacha Baron Cohen’s work. I had heard the name Ali G and had a general
idea of the type of character he was, but I had never seen any videos or movies
with Ali G in them. After doing a little
bit of research (by research I just mean watching some of Cohen’s interviews as
Ali G) I can definitely agree with Will that most of the humor in these videos
is due to incongruity and superiority.
So many of Ali G’s ridiculous statements catch the viewer off
guard. For example, while interviewing
Buzz Aldrin, Cohen asks if Buzz thinks that mankind will ever make it to the
sun. Obviously, Aldrin replies “no, the
sun is too hot” to which Cohen, as Ali G, replies “what happens if they went in
winter when the sun is cold?”. The incongruity
here is blatantly obvious and significantly contributes to our laughter. The superiority theory also comes into effect
here as we feel superior to Ali G because everyone knows that the sun is far
from cold even in the winter. Another
great moment from the Buzz Aldrin interview that showcases both incongruity and
superiority is when Ali G begins to talk about people approaching Buzz with a
conspiracy theory that we are led to believe is the theory that the moon
missions were fake, and the video evidence was made in a studio of some
kind. Instead, Ali asks Aldrin his
feelings about being approached with the conspiracy theory that the moon does
not exist. It was at this point in the
interview that I actually laughed out loud.
I don’t know how Cohen stays in character in these moments. I could never keep a straight face,
especially if I was doing something as ridiculous as accusing Steve Nash of “speaking
in Canada.” Overall, I’m glad Will chose
to write about something that I was unfamiliar with because it gave me a much-needed
laugh.
I was a huge fan back in the day and have seen the new show too. I always wonder about the strange mix of superiority and incongruity. In a way we are feeling superior to him, but at the same time there's something brilliant about the stupidity of his questions. They are so dumb that they are legitimately hard to answer, which in a way shows people being stumped by stupidity. How would we think about that?
ReplyDeleteI think that we can find just as much humor in the fact that the responses he gets to these ridiculous questions are very truthful. It seems like all the questions that the media asks now leave a lot of room for opinions and biases to be added. The ridiculous and off the wall questions that Cohen asks genuinely create honest, truthful, and for the most part, unbiased responses. I think that this drastic difference between Cohen's questions and the questions that are normally asked during an interview could be the cause of people being stumped. They go into the interview prepared to answer complex questions and are then left overthinking and just barely making it through the stupid and basic questions that Cohen gives them.
DeleteWhen Cohen asks ridiculously stupid questions they're SO funny, because like we talked about in class, I think it brings the expert down to a normal persons level. Comparing Cohen to other talk show hosts and comedians, he seems special in comparison since he makes different alias' and genuinely tricks these higher ups to be truthful about their goals. I love how serious he is throughout his ordeals, because if he ever broke character or laughed the whole scenario would be ruined.
ReplyDelete